Published

Published

Can you afford the cost of a bad hire?

Can you afford the cost of a bad hire?

No company sets out to make bad hires, but a staggering 95% of businesses make lousy hiring decisions every year. For some businesses, it is all about time pressure. 

No company sets out to make bad hires, but a staggering 95% of businesses make lousy hiring decisions every year. For some businesses, it is all about time pressure. 

Three colleagues working on laptops in an office lounge, the cost of a bad hire

No company sets out to make bad hires, but a staggering 95% of businesses make lousy hiring decisions every year. For some businesses, it is all about time pressure. 


Studies show that 30% of hiring managers choose the wrong candidate because theyโ€™re either under time pressure or simply do not know how to find the right candidate in the first place, or they lack the resources to test the effectiveness of their hiring process. 

The problem? Bad hires cost money; a lot of it. In many cases up to 30% of an employeeโ€™s salary, and thatโ€™s only the financial cost. So how much can a bad hire really cost your business, and how do you avoid making poor hiring decisions at the outset? When a new hire doesnโ€™t work out, it can have a lasting impact on your business. Here are some hidden costs of making bad hires that you should be aware of. 


Decreased morale 

Poor hiring decisions can decrease morale across your organisation. Why? Because your other employees are expected to pick up the slack or cover for their unproductive new colleague. Poor staff morale can lead to higher staff turnover, which only exacerbates hiring costs. 


Time to fill 

On average, white-collar recruitment processes can take 4-6 weeks from sign off to completion and then it can be another four weeks before the new hire actually commences. If you donโ€™t get it right the first time, you could be waiting months and have your role look less and less attractive the longer it goes unfilled. 


Decreased productivity 

Studies suggest that new employees are 50% less productive in the first three months as they settle into their new role. Repeatedly hiring new candidates for the same position can drag this out, leaving room for your competitors to take up the market share youโ€™ve lost. 


Damaged reputation 

Bad hires result in poor client or customer service, which, in turn, can damage your organisationโ€™s reputation. In Australiaโ€™s current economic climate, no organisation can afford reputation damage, especially when it can be easily avoided. 


Identifying the right talent with the help of a specialist recruiter. 

Specialists take the guesswork out of the hiring process and help you source the brightest talent for your organisation while saving money in the long run. Just like you wouldnโ€™t visit a dentist to get your hearing checked, you shouldnโ€™t outsource your hiring needs just to` anyone. Just because you use an agency that gives you great rates for your blue collar hires it doesnโ€™t mean they know what makes a great HR or procurement professional. Just as inhouse recruiters need to wear many hats they cantโ€™ be expected to know in deep detail what makes a great IT, Finance, Procurement, HR, Sales or Marketing candidate. Specialist recruiters can help you identify precisely what you need from your new hire and advise you whether you are pitching the role at the appropriate remuneration level and the likelihood of finding suitably experienced talent in the marketplace. 


Access to a quality candidate pool 

Experienced recruiters have extensive networks that allow them to pair you with the most talented and suitable candidate the first time around. They know whom to approach, quickly. Many have spent years honing their ability to identify what makes people tick and why a candidate will succeed in some environments and not others. Although itโ€™s true that not every new hire works out in the long run, you can reduce the risk of making bad hires by partnering with a specialist recruiter. And, in the current economic climate, choosing the right candidate the first time around has never been more critical. 


Evelina Samuels Managing Director seated in plaid jacket on stool, Samuels Donegan HR recruitment Australia.
Logo

Evelina Samuels

Managing Director

Related News & Insights


Related News & Insights


21 Mar, 2024

a person stacking coins on top of a table
a person stacking coins on top of a table

The Scariest Salary Question: Am I Being Paid Enough?

Ever spotted a job ad for your exact title offering $20k more and immediately questioned everything? You're not alone. We're unpacking why salary comparisons aren't always straightforward, what our latest HR salary data reveals, and how to find out where you really stand in the market.

21 Mar, 2024

person using magnifying glass enlarging the appearance of his nose and sunglasses
person using magnifying glass enlarging the appearance of his nose and sunglasses

The Curse of the Unicorn Candidate

The search for the perfect candidate can quickly become a recruitment nightmare. We're exploring why unrealistic hiring expectations can backfire, and why the best person for the job might not tick every box.

21 Mar, 2024

A white ghost costume with a wreath on its head
A white ghost costume with a wreath on its head

Ghosted: why candidates (and employers) disappear

One minute theyโ€™re โ€œsuper keenโ€, the next, silence. We look at why candidates (and employers) ghost, and the simple fixes that make honesty the easier option.

21 Mar, 2024

a man holding a sign in the middle of a crowd
a man holding a sign in the middle of a crowd

5 letters that can drastically change your job ad response

Could five letters change your job ad response? Explore a simple wording change to consider when writing your next job advertisement.

21 Mar, 2024

a man sitting at a desk talking to a woman
a man sitting at a desk talking to a woman

What happens between โ€œwe really like them!โ€ and making an offer?

What happens between finding a candidate you like and making a job offer? Explore the gap between a positive interview and the next step in hiring.

21 Mar, 2024

shallow focus photography of red and white for hire signage
shallow focus photography of red and white for hire signage

Why Now May Be the Best Time to Hire a Talent Acquisition Leader

The best time to hire a Talent Acquisition leader might be before you desperately need one. Yasmin Mohsin explores why acting ahead of the next hiring cycle could give organisations an advantage, and what great TA leadership looks like.

Iโ€™m a Jobseeker

Submit your CV and let's find you your perfect match.

Iโ€™m an Employer

Find your next dream hire with us.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.