Published

Published

How to nail that senior interview

How to nail that senior interview

No matter how well-qualified you are, if you aren’t able to express why you’re a good fit for the role, you’re not giving hiring managers a compelling reason to choose you.

No matter how well-qualified you are, if you aren’t able to express why you’re a good fit for the role, you’re not giving hiring managers a compelling reason to choose you.

Executive in a suit reading a business newspaper to prepare for a senior interview, Samuels Donegan Australia.

No matter how well-qualified you are, if you aren’t able to express why you’re a good fit for the role, you’re not giving hiring managers a compelling reason to choose you. 


This is even truer for senior level roles where there’s pressure on recruiters to find a high-value candidate to fill a pivotal position for the company. The reality is, you can’t simply show up, hand over a stellar CV, and expect to be welcomed aboard for your merits alone. 

With entry level roles, the objective is to find a candidate who can successfully handle a set of job responsibilities. At the executive level, the stakes are higher, and the interview is likely to be more intense; hiring managers have to gauge your leadership skills, capacity to deliver results, and ability to thrive within the company culture. 

The key to nailing a job interview for a senior manager or executive role is to be fully prepared. When you do the research and preparation work, you’ll feel confident when answering interview questions and present your best self. Here are four tips to help you prepare for your next senior-level job interview. 

This is even truer for senior level roles where there’s pressure on recruiters to find a high-value candidate to fill a pivotal position for the company. The reality is, you can’t simply show up, hand over a stellar CV, and expect to be welcomed aboard for your merits alone. 

With entry level roles, the objective is to find a candidate who can successfully handle a set of job responsibilities. At the executive level, the stakes are higher, and the interview is likely to be more intense; hiring managers have to gauge your leadership skills, capacity to deliver results, and ability to thrive within the company culture. 

The key to nailing a job interview for a senior manager or executive role is to be fully prepared. When you do the research and preparation work, you’ll feel confident when answering interview questions and present your best self. Here are four tips to help you prepare for your next senior-level job interview. 

Research, research, research 

Dig up as much information as you can about the organisational structure, culture, business strategy, and reputation. Use the company website, social media pages, and digital content to get a feel for the brand personality and internal culture. Use financial reports, industry journals, and press releases to learn about the company history, recent news, and future direction. Read the bios of anyone who may be interviewing you, as well as those in leadership roles to familiarise yourself with the people you may be interacting with. 

Prepare for difficult questions 

When you are interviewing for a senior manager or executive role, be prepared to answer tough questions. Any leadership position involves a lot of responsibility so you can expect questions that dig a little deeper than what you’ve experienced in other job interviews. 

During the interview, your interviewer may ask behavioural questions. These are intended to reveal how you might react in specific work scenarios. They may ask you to share examples of how you’ve performed under pressure, dealt with an interpersonal challenge at work, or learnt from mistakes. Here are a few other common behavioural questions you should be prepared to answer: 

•  How did you resolve a difficult situation with a client or vendor? 
•  What was a stressful work situation, and how did you respond to it? 
•  What professional accomplishment are you the proudest of? 
•  When was a time you struggled to work in a team, and how did you handle it? 
•  Describe a time when you persuaded a co-worker to see your perspective? 

Expect the unexpected 

The interview process is evolving, so you can’t count on traditional question-and-answer experience. Hiring managers and recruiters are using new interview techniques to gain more insights about a candidate’s soft skills, resilience, and leadership style. These can include video auditions, where you’re asked a set of behavioural questions which you must answer in a specific timeframe, high-tech assessment tools that rely on AI and behavioural science, and out-of-the-box interviews like TechnologyAdvice CEO Rob Bellenfant’s Ping Pong Games or Richard Branson’s Cab Driver Disguise. 

The more you prepare, the more you’ll gain 

There’s nothing to lose from over-preparing. And there’s a wealth of experience and insight to gain from an interview you can give your best to. You’ve already accomplished a lot professionally – that’s why you’re ready to interview for a senior-level role. Step up to this challenge and embrace it, and you’ll eventually land the dream job that will set you up for the next stage of your career. 

Dig up as much information as you can about the organisational structure, culture, business strategy, and reputation. Use the company website, social media pages, and digital content to get a feel for the brand personality and internal culture. Use financial reports, industry journals, and press releases to learn about the company history, recent news, and future direction. Read the bios of anyone who may be interviewing you, as well as those in leadership roles to familiarise yourself with the people you may be interacting with. 

Prepare for difficult questions 

When you are interviewing for a senior manager or executive role, be prepared to answer tough questions. Any leadership position involves a lot of responsibility so you can expect questions that dig a little deeper than what you’ve experienced in other job interviews. 

During the interview, your interviewer may ask behavioural questions. These are intended to reveal how you might react in specific work scenarios. They may ask you to share examples of how you’ve performed under pressure, dealt with an interpersonal challenge at work, or learnt from mistakes. Here are a few other common behavioural questions you should be prepared to answer: 

•  How did you resolve a difficult situation with a client or vendor? 
•  What was a stressful work situation, and how did you respond to it? 
•  What professional accomplishment are you the proudest of? 
•  When was a time you struggled to work in a team, and how did you handle it? 
•  Describe a time when you persuaded a co-worker to see your perspective? 

Expect the unexpected 

The interview process is evolving, so you can’t count on traditional question-and-answer experience. Hiring managers and recruiters are using new interview techniques to gain more insights about a candidate’s soft skills, resilience, and leadership style. These can include video auditions, where you’re asked a set of behavioural questions which you must answer in a specific timeframe, high-tech assessment tools that rely on AI and behavioural science, and out-of-the-box interviews like TechnologyAdvice CEO Rob Bellenfant’s Ping Pong Games or Richard Branson’s Cab Driver Disguise. 

The more you prepare, the more you’ll gain 

There’s nothing to lose from over-preparing. And there’s a wealth of experience and insight to gain from an interview you can give your best to. You’ve already accomplished a lot professionally – that’s why you’re ready to interview for a senior-level role. Step up to this challenge and embrace it, and you’ll eventually land the dream job that will set you up for the next stage of your career. 

Evelina Samuels Managing Director seated in plaid jacket on stool, Samuels Donegan HR recruitment Australia.
Logo

Evelina Samuels

Managing Director

Related News & Insights


Related News & Insights


21 Mar, 2024

a person stacking coins on top of a table
a person stacking coins on top of a table

The Scariest Salary Question: Am I Being Paid Enough?

Ever spotted a job ad for your exact title offering $20k more and immediately questioned everything? You're not alone. We're unpacking why salary comparisons aren't always straightforward, what our latest HR salary data reveals, and how to find out where you really stand in the market.

21 Mar, 2024

person using magnifying glass enlarging the appearance of his nose and sunglasses
person using magnifying glass enlarging the appearance of his nose and sunglasses

The Curse of the Unicorn Candidate

The search for the perfect candidate can quickly become a recruitment nightmare. We're exploring why unrealistic hiring expectations can backfire, and why the best person for the job might not tick every box.

21 Mar, 2024

A white ghost costume with a wreath on its head
A white ghost costume with a wreath on its head

Ghosted: why candidates (and employers) disappear

One minute they’re “super keen”, the next, silence. We look at why candidates (and employers) ghost, and the simple fixes that make honesty the easier option.

21 Mar, 2024

a man holding a sign in the middle of a crowd
a man holding a sign in the middle of a crowd

5 letters that can drastically change your job ad response

Could five letters change your job ad response? Explore a simple wording change to consider when writing your next job advertisement.

21 Mar, 2024

a man sitting at a desk talking to a woman
a man sitting at a desk talking to a woman

What happens between “we really like them!” and making an offer?

What happens between finding a candidate you like and making a job offer? Explore the gap between a positive interview and the next step in hiring.

21 Mar, 2024

shallow focus photography of red and white for hire signage
shallow focus photography of red and white for hire signage

Why Now May Be the Best Time to Hire a Talent Acquisition Leader

The best time to hire a Talent Acquisition leader might be before you desperately need one. Yasmin Mohsin explores why acting ahead of the next hiring cycle could give organisations an advantage, and what great TA leadership looks like.

I’m a Jobseeker

Submit your CV and let's find you your perfect match.

I’m an Employer

Find your next dream hire with us.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be kept informed of the latest insights and trends in the People and Talent world?

Australian Aboriginal flag with black and red halves and a yellow circle, shown by Samuels Donegan

Samuels Donegan acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land where we work and live and pay our respects to Elders past and present.