Permanent vs Temporary vs Contract HR Hiring: What’s the Difference?
An ongoing HR role to fill? Parental leave to cover? A project that needs specialist expertise, yesterday? Different hiring needs call for different solutions.
Permanent, fixed term, temporary, contract and interim HR hiring each serve a different purpose. The key differences come down to employment arrangements, duration, flexibility and the expertise your business needs.
With permanent and fixed term recruitment, the HR professional is employed directly by your organisation. Through Samuels Donegan’s On Demand Talent service, we employ and pay your temporary, contract or interim HR professional, while you pay an agreed hourly or daily rate.
Whether you're building your HR team, managing a period of change or bringing in specialist expertise, choosing the right hiring approach can make all the difference.
As a Melbourne based specialist HR recruitment agency supporting employers across Australia, Samuels Donegan helps businesses navigate these options and connect with experienced HR professionals who can make an impact.
Here’s how permanent, fixed term, temporary, contract and interim HR hiring compare, and when each option makes sense.
Your HR Hiring Options at a Glance
On Demand Talent
Temporary, contract and interim
Some roles need someone who’s in it for the long run. A permanent HR hire joins your organisation on an ongoing basis, building relationships, shaping your culture and helping your team deliver what’s next.
We get to know your business, your team and what success looks like before introducing people who bring the right skills and approach. Our current average fill time for permanent HR roles is 17 days, with timing depending on the role’s seniority and complexity.
Hiring a Head of People, HR Director or Chief People Officer? Our Executive Search service maps the market and connects with experienced leaders, including those who aren’t actively looking.
You know the role has an end date, but you want someone fully embedded in your team until then. A fixed-term HR hire joins your payroll for an agreed period, whether they’re covering parental leave, delivering a project or helping drive a transformation program.
We’ll help you find someone who can get up to speed, build the relationships that matter and make their time count.
In Australia, fixed-term contracts generally can’t run for more than two years, including extensions or renewals, and restrictions apply to consecutive contracts. Exceptions apply. Check the Fair Work Ombudsman’s guidance for the rules relevant to your situation.
Temporary,
Contract and Interim HR Hiring
A sudden vacancy. A project that can’t wait. A leadership gap while you find your next permanent hire. Sometimes, you need experienced HR support ready to step in.
Our On Demand Talent service connects you with temporary, contract and interim HR professionals who are immediately available and ready to jump in. We employ and pay them, and you pay an agreed hourly or daily rate, with engagement terms confirmed upfront.
Our interim hires average two days from brief to placement. Tell us what you need, and we’ll get moving.
Temporary HR Support
Keep things moving when someone’s away, workloads spike or a vacancy catches you off guard. Temporary HR support gives your team an extra pair of experienced hands, usually for days to a few months.
Contract HR Specialists
Bring in the expertise to get a specific piece of work done. From Enterprise Agreement negotiations and HRIS rollouts to restructures and building a talent acquisition function, we’ll help you find someone who knows the work and can get stuck in.
Interim HR Leaders
A senior departure doesn’t put your people priorities on pause. An interim HR leader steps in to guide the team, make decisions and maintain momentum while you work out your next move.
Need help finding the permanent replacement too? We can manage both searches and plan the handover.
How to Choose the Right Type of HR Hire
Is the need ongoing or for a set period?
Ongoing points to permanent. A known end date points to fixed-term, temporary or contract.
How quickly do you need someone?
If it’s this week, On Demand Talent is usually the fastest route.
Do you have approval for a permanent hire?
If permanent headcount isn’t approved, temporary, contract or interim HR support may offer another way to meet the need, subject to your organisation’s budget and approval processes.
Is it a specialist piece of work?
A contractor with deep experience in that area can often deliver faster than building the capability in-house.
What’s the difference between a fixed-term employee and a contractor?
A fixed-term employee is employed directly by you until an agreed end date, and is part of your payroll. A contractor engaged through Samuels Donegan’s On Demand Talent service is employed and paid by us, and you pay us an hourly or daily rate for their time.
Who looks after pay, super and tax for On Demand Talent?
We do. Samuels Donegan handles pay, superannuation and tax for the HR professionals employed through our On Demand Talent service, reducing payroll administration for your team.
Can a temporary or contract HR professional become permanent?
If someone’s a great fit and you’d like to offer them a permanent role, talk to us. We’ll explain how it works for your situation.
Is temporary or contract support more expensive than a permanent hire?
It depends on the role, duration and support you need. An On Demand Talent hourly or daily charge rate includes employment costs and our service, so it shouldn’t be compared with base salary alone. For a permanent hire, consider salary, superannuation, leave entitlements and the recruitment fee. We’ll explain the costs upfront so you can compare the options for your team.
Know what needs doing, but not who to hire?
Tell us where your team needs support. We’ll help you choose the right hiring approach and find the person to move things forward.
I’m a Jobseeker
Submit your CV and let's find you your perfect match.
I’m an Employer
Find your next dream hire with us.
